The Supreme Court of Ukraine has remanded the case involving the religious studies expert opinion by the DESS against the Ukrainian Orthodox Church for reconsideration

The Supreme Court of Ukraine ruled to overturn the verdicts of the lower courts in a case concerning the legality of a religious studies expert assessment, on the basis of which a list was compiled of religious organizations that, in the opinion of government agencies, with religious centers in the Russian Federation. According to uoc-news.church, the case has been remanded to the court of first instance for reconsideration.
The legal proceedings were initiated by the Kyiv Metropolis of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, the Pochaiv Holy Dormition Lavra, and the Holy Florovsk Convent. The plaintiffs challenged a decision by the Ministry of Culture of Ukraine, which was based on the findings of an expert review conducted by the State Service of Ukraine for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience (DESS). Diocesan administrations, monasteries, and other church institutions had previously fallen under the scope of this regulatory act.
According to the Supreme Court’s ruling, the decisions of the Kyiv District Administrative Court dated May 15, 2023, and the ruling of the Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal dated November 2, 2023, were overturned. The court of first instance must now re-evaluate all arguments and evidence presented by the parties to determine the legality of the expert opinion that served as the basis for compiling the list of UOC religious organizations which, according to the DESS, are “affiliated” with the Moscow Patriarchate and subject to a ban at the state level. This ruling by the Supreme Court is final and not subject to further appeal, which effectively returns the dispute over the legality of the Ministry of Culture’s order to the review stage.
As a reminder, we previously reported that the head of the State Service for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience (DESS), Viktor Yelensky, was unable to provide specific examples of how the Moscow Patriarchate controls the Ukrainian Orthodox Church (UOC).







