In the Vinnytsia region, a court fined a soldier for refusing to take the oath on religious grounds

In the Vinnytsia region, the Chechelnytskyi District Court ruled to impose an administrative penalty on a mobilized soldier who refused to take the military oath, citing his religious beliefs. The incident occurred on September 11, 2026, when the soldier disregarded a direct order from his unit commander.
The man, a member of the Evangelical Christian Church, justified his refusal by citing the tenets of his faith, which prohibit taking up arms. During the court proceedings, he also claimed that his mobilization was unlawful, asserting that he had been detained on the street and held at a regional recruitment center (RRC) for two days without receiving a draft notice. The servicemember also insisted that he had health issues which, according to him, required him to undergo a military medical examination.
However, the court found these arguments unconvincing. The ruling emphasizes that, although Article 35 of the Constitution guarantees freedom of religion, it does not exempt citizens from fulfilling their duties to the state. The court explained that current legislation provides for alternative service exclusively in lieu of active-duty service, but not in lieu of mobilization training. Since the servicemember did not provide evidence of an appeal against the actions of the Territorial Military Commissariat and did not confirm the existence of official medical reports declaring him unfit for service, he was found guilty under Part 1 of Article 172-10 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses. The case resulted in a fine of 1,700 hryvnias, as well as the collection of court fees.
As a reminder, it was previously reported that the Supreme Court of Ukraine issued a key legal ruling stating that religious beliefs do not constitute grounds for exemption from military service during mobilization and do not negate criminal liability for evasion. This position was expressed by the Joint Chamber of the Criminal Court of Cassation, which emphasized that the law does not provide for exemptions from military duty during mobilization on the basis of religious belief.







